Vikas said: To describe Romila Thapar, I would like to employ (with slight variation) an History of Early India: From the origins to AD by Romila Thapar is. Possehl delineates the Early Harappan cultures and presents his ideas on the transition to the Mature Harappan. Sonawane gives a brief review of regional. Out of Print. Early India From the Origins to AD by Romila Thapar (Author). Title Details. ISBN: ISBN: Stay Informed.
|Published (Last):||20 October 2007|
|PDF File Size:||2.59 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||19.33 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
And there is plenty of interesting subject matter in this book.
The wotk however early india by romila thapar well researched and you feel like sitting in a time machine. Thapar has incorporated the vast changes in scholarly understanding and interpretation of Indian history that have occurred during her lifetime to revise the book for a new generation of readers.
This is an erudite and impressive work. See All Goodreads Deals…. Shopbop Designer Fashion Brands. Be thapad Ram Guha or Romila Thapar they mastered the art of demeaning India’s past, fabricating theories and applying early india by romila thapar sense of righteousness in their history telling.
For a reader who just wants to explore the undia history of India and its relations with contemporary for non-academic purposes or for a light reader who need not mug up so much details the first few chapters may seem very interesting especially because of the limited data, language, interpretation etc. Some Interpretations; History and Beyond; Sakuntala: Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account.
What you get in the book are nearly pages of small type taking a thematic and chronological approach that passes from across the different regions within the sub-continent, following similarities and differences and interactions.
History Of Early India From The Origins To AD 1300 – author Romila Thapar
Feb 18, Tarun Bhargava rated it really liked it. If you’ve seen “Gandhi” you’ll know there were terrible massacres perpetrated after partition in Why are there so few truly ancient temples in a land whose history goes back years — most existing temples are less than a years old.
This feels more like a dispassionate approach to bj subject, however controversial that might feel see the other reviews for some diametrically opposed views on Thaar approach. Overall, the book is a pretty good resource for a specialist, just to get early india by romila thapar names and dates and places of your rajas, cakravartins, and texts, and I’d imagine very frustrating for anyone else.
I like the fact that she covers the sources archeological, literary of how we know what we know about history. University of Early india by romila thapar Press; 1st edition February 1, Language: Some think Indian early india by romila thapar can be boiled down to the Hindu vs Muslim angle, or the lost Golden Age angle, bg the Victorian or Marxist angle.
I will mention only a few: Gives a very good overview of the history of this period, along with a useful bibliography if you want to go deeper in the study of Indian history. Would you like to tell us about a lower price? Get to Know Us. Throws some new light on the formation romula the caste society in India and the indi and dynamics of the political-economy in both south and north India.
I am not Indian and I have no political agenda.
Nov 20, Moureen rated it it was indka. Now while reviewing this book I faced a challenge that forced me t Review originally posted in Abby’s Shelf: Journals with no new volumes being added to the archive. This is where Thapar begins this book, by examining the different schools early india by romila thapar thought regarding the history of India.
Early India: From the Origins to AD – Romila Thapar – Google Books
If someone wanted to skim the book, reading the conclusion paragraphs would be a good way to do so. I would highly recommend this to anyone who is interested in the early history of India. To describe Romila Thapar, I would like to employ with slight variation an unknown quote by a famous journalist for Indira Gandhi, “She is the only MAN among the Indian intellectuals” Early India is one early india by romila thapar the best books I have read this year. The gradual development of the caste system and its hold on Indian social life till early india by romila thapar is explained very well.
Amazon Rapids Fun stories for kids on the go. This one contains the accumulated research of the last thirty years and includes richly textured accounts of idnia in ancient India. Thapar cautions against the temptation to focus on dominant cultures but her own analysis tilts in that very direction. D To ca Penguin claims this book “brings Indian Early india by romila thapar to life”. Page 1 of 1 Start over Page 1 of 1. There is no way that the Indo European language family originated in Rromila West India, so call that one a draw.
: Early India: From the Origins to AD (): Romila Thapar: Books
I would posit that this book and its author kill Indian history, dismember the corpse, burn the remains and plod mechanically through the ashes. She domila a lot of interesting ideas early india by romila thapar regarding how history has been viewed.
The fact that Harappan civilisation is part of a longer, complex story that involves many earlier, less glamorous cultures is not brought out.
My library Help Advanced Book Search. We’ll provide a PDF copy for your screen reader. The PURANAS, claiming to record the past, were now authored by brahmans and written in Sanskrit, although there was often a pretense that they were still being recited by the bard who was placed formally in the role of the original composer.
Sadly, I feel that Thapar cannot write otherwise. But her narrative glosses over the enormous difficulties in dating the Vedas and in extracting history out of them. Sure, history is sometimes like that and forcing an ideological narrative is not something I want, but it should be possible to have a somewhat loose narrative thread of sorts to make it easier to make sense of what’s going on. Sadly, her evidence for this judgement is so vague that I can’t say whether she has a point or not.
Now while reviewing this book I faced a challenge that forced me early india by romila thapar take a different approach in reviewing this book. The scope of the Early india by romila thapar is geographically wide-ranging and covers the following spectrum of disciplines: I was looking for a book which early india by romila thapar me stories about Indian history, instead I got a soulless Marxist manifesto.
A History of India, vol.
Overall, the first few chapters are a fairly good introduction to early India, but it gets too disorganised to follow soon after. Open Preview See a Problem? Sep 30, P. Tahpar said, it entertained me for the most early india by romila thapar, and informed me a great deal about Indian societies of the past.